Pay down the mortgage or contribute to an RRSP?
Prepaying a mortgage earns a guaranteed, tax-free return equal to your mortgage rate. An RRSP gives you a tax refund now and tax-sheltered growth, but is taxed on the way out. Which wins depends on three numbers – and on what you do with the refund.
What each option really earns
- Prepaying the mortgage: every dollar you prepay saves the interest you would have paid on it. At a 5% mortgage rate, that is like earning 5% after tax with no risk – a hard return to beat.
- RRSP: you get a refund at your marginal rate today, the money grows without tax, and withdrawals are taxed at your marginal rate in retirement. The investment return is not guaranteed.
The three numbers that decide it: your mortgage rate, the return you expect on your RRSP investments, and your tax rate now vs in retirement.
A worked example
You have $7,000 of savings to put somewhere this year. Your marginal tax rate is 30% and your mortgage rate is 5%. We look 10 years ahead. To keep the arithmetic clear, assume the RRSP also earns 5% a year, and treat prepaid mortgage money as "earning" the 5% interest it saves, compounded yearly. 1.05 multiplied 10 times is 1.6289.
| Option | Calculation | After-tax value |
|---|---|---|
| A. Prepay the mortgage | $7,000 × 1.6289 | $11,402 |
| B. RRSP, spend the refund | $7,000 × 1.6289 = $11,402, less 30% tax on withdrawal | $7,982 |
| C. RRSP, refund prepays mortgage | $7,982 + ($2,100 refund × 1.6289 = $3,421) | $11,402 |
| D. TFSA | $7,000 × 1.6289, no tax | $11,402 |
Figures are rounded to the nearest dollar, so sums can be off by $1.
What this shows:
- When the RRSP earns the same as the mortgage rate and your tax rate is the same at withdrawal, A, C and D tie.
- Option B loses by $3,420. An RRSP only works if the refund is put to work too. Spending it is what makes "RRSP vs mortgage" a bad comparison for many people.
When the numbers change
- Lower tax rate in retirement. If you withdraw at 20% instead of 30%, option C becomes $9,122 + $3,421 = $12,543, beating prepaying by about $1,140.
- Higher investment return. If the RRSP earns 6% while the mortgage costs 5%, the RRSP grows to $12,536, or $8,775 after 30% tax; plus the prepaid refund, C reaches $12,196. But 6% is not guaranteed; the mortgage saving is.
- Higher tax rate in retirement (for example a large pension, or OAS recovery tax) or a high mortgage rate tilts the answer toward prepaying.
Do both: use the refund to prepay
A popular middle path: contribute to your RRSP, then put the whole tax refund on the mortgage as a lump-sum prepayment. You get tax-sheltered retirement savings and a smaller mortgage. Two practical tips:
- Make the prepayment the day the refund arrives, before it disappears into spending.
- Check that your lump-sum prepayment fits within your mortgage's yearly prepayment privilege.
Prepayment privileges and penalties
Most closed mortgages let you prepay a set amount each year without penalty – for example by raising your regular payment or making a lump-sum payment up to a percentage of the original amount. The limits are in your mortgage contract and vary by lender. Go over them and you pay a prepayment penalty, usually the higher of:
- three months' interest on the balance, or
- the interest rate differential (IRD), roughly the interest the lender loses because current rates are lower than yours, over the rest of the term.
The IRD can be large. In the Financial Consumer Agency of Canada's example, on a $200,000 balance at 6% with 36 months left, three months' interest is about $3,000 but the IRD is about $12,000 – and the penalty is the higher figure. Open mortgages allow unlimited prepayment, but at a higher rate.
The third option: a TFSA
A TFSA gives no refund, but withdrawals are tax-free and don't count as income. As the table shows, it matches prepaying when returns match – and unlike a prepaid mortgage, the money stays available for emergencies. It is often the best choice if your income is modest now, if you expect a similar or higher tax rate in retirement, or if you get the Guaranteed Income Supplement later. Many people use a TFSA to save up and then prepay the mortgage at renewal, when there is no penalty.
When each one wins
| Prepaying the mortgage tends to win when… | An RRSP tends to win when… |
|---|---|
| your mortgage rate is high | your marginal rate is high now and will be lower in retirement |
| you would spend the refund | you reinvest or prepay with the refund |
| you value certainty and being debt-free by retirement | your employer matches contributions (always take the match) |
| your expected retirement tax rate is as high as today's | you have a long time horizon and accept investment risk |
Whatever you choose, have an emergency fund first and pay off higher-interest debt such as credit cards before either. For the RRSP side of the decision, see How an RRSP saves tax and RRSP, TFSA or FHSA?.